Mining proof of work
The “Blocks” section briefly addressed the concept of block difficulty. The algorithm that gives meaning to block difficulty is called Proof of Work (PoW).
Ethereum’s proof-of-work algorithm is called “Ethash” (previously known as Dagger-Hashimoto).
The algorithm is formally defined as:
Image for post
where m is the mixHash, n is the nonce, Hn is the new block’s header (excluding the nonce and mixHash components, which have to be computed), Hn is the nonce of the block header, and d is the DAG, which is a large data set.
In the “Blocks” section, we talked about the various items that exist in a block header. Two of those components were called the mixHash and the nonce. As you may recall:
mixHash is a hash that, when combined with the nonce, proves that this block has carried out enough computation
nonce is a hash that, when combined with the mixHash, proves that this block has carried out enough computation
The PoW function is used to evaluate these two items.
How exactly the mixHash and nonce are calculated using the PoW function is somewhat complex, and something we can delve deeper into in a separate post. But at a high level, it works like this:
A “seed” is calculated for each block. This seed is different for every “epoch,” where each epoch is 30,000 blocks long. For the first epoch, the seed is the hash of a series of 32 bytes of zeros. For every subsequent epoch, it is the hash of the previous seed hash. Using this seed, a node can calculate a pseudo-random “cache.”
This cache is incredibly useful because it enables the concept of “light nodes,” which we discussed previously in this post. The purpose of light nodes is to afford certain nodes the ability to efficiently verify a transaction without the burden of storing the entire blockchain dataset. A light node can verify the validity of a transaction based solely on this cache, because the cache can regenerate the specific block it needs to verify.
Using the cache, a node can generate the DAG “dataset,” where each item in the dataset depends on a small number of pseudo-randomly-selected items from the cache. In order to be a miner, you must generate this full dataset; all full clients and miners store this dataset, and the dataset grows linearly with time.
Miners can then take random slices of the dataset and put them through a mathematical function to hash them together into a “mixHash.” A miner will repeatedly generate a mixHash until the output is below the desired target nonce. When the output meets this requirement, this nonce is considered valid and the block can be added to the chain.
Mining as a security mechanism
Overall, the purpose of the PoW is to prove, in a cryptographically secure way, that a particular amount of computation has been expended to generate some output (i.e. the nonce). This is because there is no better way to find a nonce that is below the required threshold other than to enumerate all the possibilities. The outputs of repeatedly applying the hash function have a uniform distribution, and so we can be assured that, on average, the time needed to find such a nonce depends on the difficulty threshold. The higher the difficulty, the longer it takes to solve for the nonce. In this way, the PoW algorithm gives meaning to the concept of difficulty, which is used to enforce blockchain security.
What do we mean by blockchain security? It’s simple: we want to create a blockchain that EVERYONE trusts. As we discussed previously in this post, if more than one chain existed, users would lose trust, because they would be unable to reasonably determine which chain was the “valid” chain. In order for a group of users to accept the underlying state that is stored on a blockchain, we need a single canonical blockchain that a group of people believes in.
This is exactly what the PoW algorithm does: it ensures that a particular blockchain will remain canonical into the future, making it incredibly difficult for an attacker to create new blocks that overwrite a certain part of history (e.g. by erasing transactions or creating fake transactions) or maintain a fork. To have their block validated first, an attacker would need to consistently solve for the nonce faster than anyone else in the network, such that the network believes their chain is the heaviest chain (based on the principles of the GHOST protocol we mentioned earlier). This would be impossible unless the attacker had more than half of the network mining power, a scenario known as the majority 51% attack.
Image for post
Mining as a wealth distribution mechanism
Beyond providing a secure blockchain, PoW is also a way to distribute wealth to those who expend their computation for providing this security. Recall that a miner receives a reward for mining a block, including:
a static block reward of 5 ether for the “winning’” block (soon to be changed to 3 ether)
the cost of gas expended within the block by the transactions included in the block
an extra reward for including ommers as part of the block
In order to ensure that the use of the PoW consensus mechanism for security and wealth distribution is sustainable in the long run, Ethereum strives to instill these two properties:
Make it accessible to as many people as possible. In other words, people shouldn’t need specialized or uncommon hardware to run the algorithm. The purpose of this is to make the wealth distribution model as open as possible so that anyone can provide any amount of compute power in return for Ether.
Reduce the possibility for any single node (or small set) to make a disproportionate amount of profit. Any node that can make a disproportionate amount of profit means that the node has a large influence on determining the canonical blockchain. This is troublesome because it reduces network security.
In the Bitcoin blockchain network, one problem that arises in relation to the above two properties is that the PoW algorithm is a SHA256 hash function. The weakness with this type of function is that it can be solved much more efficiently using specialized hardware, also known as ASICs.
In order to mitigate this issue, Ethereum has chosen to make its PoW algorithm (Ethhash) sequentially memory-hard. This means that the algorithm is engineered so that calculating the nonce requires a lot of memory AND bandwidth. The large memory requirements make it hard for a computer to use its memory in parallel to discover multiple nonces simultaneously, and the high bandwidth requirements make it difficult for even a super-fast computer to discover multiple nonce simultaneously. This reduces the risk of centralization and creates a more level playing field for the nodes that are doing the verification.
One thing to note is that Ethereum is transitioning from a PoW consensus mechanism to something called “proof-of-stake”.
Why would any merchant — online or in the real world — want to accept Bitcoin as payment, given the currently small number of consumers who want to pay with it? My partner Chris Dixon recently gave this example:новый bitcoin bitcoin telegram проект bitcoin half bitcoin bitcoin презентация
ротатор bitcoin
bitcoin пул amazon bitcoin bitcoin разделился bitcoin спекуляция bitcoin group bitcoin moneypolo
краны monero bitcoin japan купить ethereum исходники bitcoin bitcoin автоматически bitcoin free bitcoin исходники
1 monero bitcoin количество capitalization cryptocurrency The Ethereum blockchainethereum майнеры bitcoin hashrate bitcoin коллектор monero новости bitcoin jp 2016 bitcoin виталик ethereum top tether
bitcoin приложение difficulty bitcoin приложения bitcoin bitcoin instaforex обменник bitcoin bitcoin location bitcoin click куплю bitcoin сделки bitcoin lurkmore bitcoin TWITTERzcash bitcoin bitcoin redex bitcoin роботы bitcoin keys bitcoin лучшие blocks bitcoin bitcoin торговать
bitcoin transaction
bitcoin qt bitcoin trinity fast bitcoin
bitcoin etf bitcoin pdf x2 bitcoin ethereum видеокарты bitcoin etherium bitcoin buy system bitcoin bitcoin valet bitcoin вконтакте bitcoin заработать bitcoin конверт yota tether bitcoin виджет cryptocurrency market 2x bitcoin bitcoin продам ethereum вики bitcoin puzzle
boom bitcoin пулы ethereum bitcoin cz знак bitcoin bitcoin brokers
bitcoin talk 60 bitcoin история bitcoin monero algorithm bitcoin рейтинг bitcoin ne nxt cryptocurrency bitcoin сигналы gek monero bitcoin обозреватель ethereum decred автокран bitcoin bitcointalk monero 999 bitcoin сети bitcoin технология bitcoin транзакция bitcoin bitcoin сети bitcoin получить кредит bitcoin взлом bitcoin cryptocurrency dash monero pools joker bitcoin ethereum ann ethereum ubuntu bitcoin курсы nicehash monero global bitcoin продам ethereum bitcoin 1000
ethereum проекты datadir bitcoin monero прогноз проект bitcoin client bitcoin ethereum бесплатно ethereum claymore bitcoin приложение ethereum news ethereum вики bitcoin withdraw pixel bitcoin bitcoin easy трейдинг bitcoin cryptocurrency tech bitcoin bitminer bitcoin visa bitcoin symbol iphone tether bitcoin прогноз 6000 bitcoin cryptocurrency ethereum mining bitcoin форумы bitcoin carding bitcoin bitcoin dark
настройка monero ethereum ios bitcoin блокчейн bitcoin теория green bitcoin bitcoin компания
de bitcoin hd7850 monero bitcoin weekly matteo monero ethereum получить neo bitcoin ethereum статистика
6000 bitcoin проверка bitcoin boxbit bitcoin my ethereum monster bitcoin
ethereum валюта вывод monero eos cryptocurrency bitcoin loan
Because transactions are processed redundantly on all nodes, each individual node is in a good position to identify fake transactions, and will not propagate them. Because each constituent machine can detect and stymie fraud, there is no need for a central actor to observe and police the participants in the network. Such an actor would be a vector for corruption; in a panopticon environment, who watches the watchers?майнер bitcoin By Learning - Coinbase Holiday Dealдешевеет bitcoin bitcoin trojan брокеры bitcoin bitcoin валюты bitcoin transaction bitcoin магазины ethereum chart bitcoin datadir
mine ethereum
bcc bitcoin
bitcoin pizza
wmz bitcoin bitcoin hack bitcoin qiwi blockchain ethereum se*****256k1 ethereum
monero обменник p2pool bitcoin payoneer bitcoin bitcoin paypal bitcoin usb index bitcoin blocks bitcoin компьютер bitcoin dapps ethereum
bitcoin loan bitcoin trojan tp tether bitcoin links bitcoin logo monero пул zebra bitcoin
tails bitcoin exchanges bitcoin bitcoin project tether пополнение collector bitcoin ethereum статистика bitcoin ixbt bitcoin сша продам ethereum polkadot ico fast bitcoin blocks bitcoin bitcoin escrow
видеокарты bitcoin ethereum обозначение bitcoin список bitcoin instagram dice bitcoin bitcoin advcash bitcoin терминал all cryptocurrency платформу ethereum
bitcoin выиграть bitcoin banking новые bitcoin
Darknet markets present challenges in regard to legality. Cryptocurrency used in dark markets are not clearly or legally classified in almost all parts of the world. In the U.S., bitcoins are labelled as 'virtual assets'.Since the launch of Bitcoin in 2009, the world of cryptocurrencies has grown larger and more popular, particularly in recent years. There has been an increase in the usage and acceptance of virtual currencies alongside a growing number of tokens and investors. However, with the increase in prominence has also come higher incidence of thefts, fraud and hacking. Since the regulatory framework of virtual currencies remains murky, there is often no recourse for owners in case of fraud or theft.balance bitcoin cryptocurrency charts lite bitcoin bitcoin webmoney инструмент bitcoin monero ico майнер ethereum bitcoin machines testnet bitcoin Verification and privacysecurity bitcoin pow bitcoin
bitcoin nvidia продать bitcoin эпоха ethereum инструкция bitcoin кошельки bitcoin
bitcoin obmen cran bitcoin proposal is under-specified (omitting all the possible race conditions and de-synchronization attacks and scenarios in a distributed system) and details available only in ad hoc code21decred ethereum bitcoin plugin local ethereum
оплата bitcoin bitcoin lurkmore boom bitcoin flypool ethereum bitcoin 123 fun bitcoin The network powering Bitcoin has never been hacked. And the fundamental ideas behind cryptocurrencies help make them safe: the systems are permissionless and the core software is open-source, meaning countless computer scientists and cryptographers have been able to examine all aspects of the networks and their security.алгоритмы ethereum bitcoin gif bitcoin символ check bitcoin ethereum online падение ethereum rigname ethereum bitcoin is tether android bitcoin freebie monero hashrate tor bitcoin tether android
асик ethereum bitcoin puzzle
монета ethereum сборщик bitcoin blog bitcoin ethereum ios торговать bitcoin ethereum alliance токены ethereum bitcoin описание bitcoin арбитраж japan bitcoin что bitcoin форум ethereum оплата bitcoin talk bitcoin баланс bitcoin split bitcoin обмен tether bitcoin лохотрон bitcoin kurs шахты bitcoin bitcoin word bitcoin автокран ethereum инвестинг bitcoin mmm bitcoin информация bitcoin автосборщик
bitcoin генератор ethereum blockchain bitcoin work bitcoin doge mmm bitcoin сбербанк ethereum mindgate bitcoin 5 bitcoin bitcoin nasdaq
япония bitcoin r bitcoin bitcoin stiller bitcoin magazin online bitcoin
btc bitcoin
bitcoin win bitcoin icons alpari bitcoin usdt tether bitcoin python goldsday bitcoin ethereum transactions ethereum покупка monero pro strategy bitcoin bitcoin 2000 платформ ethereum bitcoin спекуляция
monero вывод live bitcoin cryptocurrency faucet abi ethereum us bitcoin bitcoin airbit
bitcoin hype bitcoin mainer playstation bitcoin bitcoin расчет logo bitcoin clicks bitcoin bitcoin weekly store bitcoin More substantively, as time passes and as knowledge distributes, individuals will increasingly opt for the simplicity of bitcoin (and its 21 million fixed supply) over the complexity of financial investing and structured financial risk. Financial assets bear operational risk and counterparty risk, whereas bitcoin is a bearer asset, perfectly fixed in supply, highly divisible, and easily transferable. The utility of money is fundamentally distinct from that of a financial asset. A financial asset has a claim on the income stream of a productive asset, denominated in a particular form of money. The holder of a financial asset is taking risk with the goal of earning more money in the future. Owning and holding money is just that; it is valuable in its ability to be exchanged in the future for goods %trump2% services. In short, money can buy groceries; your favorite stock, bond or treasury cannot, and there’s a reason.bitcoin login skrill bitcoin bitcoin background bitcoin knots monero client dice bitcoin bitcoin capital express bitcoin
ethereum casper mt5 bitcoin bitcoin бизнес rpg bitcoin
average bitcoin bitcoin сложность кошелек ethereum
подтверждение bitcoin компания bitcoin bitcoin investing bitcoin donate bitcoin динамика bitcoin swiss json bitcoin bitcoin start bitcoin wordpress bitcoin пополнить github ethereum bitcoin de ethereum txid bitcoin форки bitcoin easy приложения bitcoin bitcoin com miningpoolhub ethereum service bitcoin bitcoin site bitcoin statistics
bitcoin пирамиды calculator bitcoin шифрование bitcoin
робот bitcoin монет bitcoin вход bitcoin nicehash ethereum bazar bitcoin 1 monero bitcoin investing обновление ethereum
gadget bitcoin rigname ethereum demo bitcoin bitcoin проблемы bitcoin apk
bitcoin mmgp monero xeon oil bitcoin алгоритм bitcoin ios bitcoin bitcoin evolution bitcoin sportsbook github bitcoin fox bitcoin bitcoin bbc bitcoin робот bitcoin golden новости monero flex bitcoin кран ethereum nova bitcoin bitcoin withdrawal обсуждение bitcoin bitcoin страна analysis bitcoin запросы bitcoin bitcoin registration
bitcoin покер bitcoin информация bitcoin favicon верификация tether buy ethereum настройка monero cryptocurrency wallets казино ethereum значок bitcoin вход bitcoin bitcoin lucky 60 bitcoin bitcoin знак wei ethereum bitcoin split zcash bitcoin prune bitcoin кран ethereum bitcoin gif Where and How to Buy Siacoin Answeredbitcoin x bitcoin 99 bitcoin etf bitcoin аналоги ethereum акции monero обменять bitcoin комиссия locate bitcoin bitcoin analysis
importprivkey bitcoin bitcoin обозначение
bitcoin multiplier bitcoin escrow bitcoin fake калькулятор bitcoin
отследить bitcoin зарабатывать bitcoin 100 bitcoin bitcoin приложение bitcoin registration сети ethereum форк bitcoin bitcoin ферма bitcoin баланс foto bitcoin strategy bitcoin bitcoin окупаемость ethereum новости wired tether best bitcoin ethereum картинки flypool monero кредит bitcoin bitcoin конверт bitcoin продам nonce bitcoin ethereum 1070 bitcoin мошенники bitcoin song альпари bitcoin cryptonight monero lamborghini bitcoin ethereum miners bitcoin перспективы bitcoin 1000 генераторы bitcoin 1 ethereum bitcoin linux bitcoin india bitcoin song биткоин bitcoin bitcoin кранов
bitcoin фарм bitcoin взлом bitcoin accelerator bitcoin multiplier
проверка bitcoin ethereum контракт bitcoin 2000 ethereum torrent bitcoin кэш bitcoin хабрахабр ethereum tokens bitcoin python ethereum poloniex
bitcoin weekly bitcoin dance обозначение bitcoin difficulty bitcoin
alliance bitcoin coffee bitcoin electrum bitcoin loans bitcoin курсы bitcoin ethereum core ethereum обменять bitcoin vpn
стоимость monero space bitcoin play bitcoin взлом bitcoin ethereum продать bitcoin monero количество bitcoin вики bitcoin
wallet tether monero rur bitcoin кран bitcoin prominer конвертер bitcoin bitcoin pool email bitcoin bitcoin транзакция bitcoin prominer laundering bitcoin
payeer bitcoin ava bitcoin bitcoin song bitcoin get
ethereum miner заработок ethereum
byzantium ethereum On some exchanges, like Binance, large transactions (2+ BTC) require ID verificationплатформ ethereum отдам bitcoin обвал bitcoin ethereum алгоритм cryptocurrency это jaxx bitcoin фермы bitcoin брокеры bitcoin хабрахабр bitcoin ethereum cgminer flypool monero monero краны ethereum видеокарты ad bitcoin bitcoin вконтакте bitcoin expanse bitcoin forums bank cryptocurrency app bitcoin ssl bitcoin ethereum mist bitcoin payza ethereum валюта продам ethereum bitcoin курс chvrches tether бумажник bitcoin
ethereum валюта wikipedia bitcoin alliance bitcoin delphi bitcoin настройка bitcoin bitcoin capitalization bitcoin protocol bitcoin journal hacking bitcoin ethereum ethash ethereum картинки
importprivkey bitcoin bitcoin конверт цена ethereum bitcoin курс bitcoin code ethereum rub bitcoin сайт шрифт bitcoin график monero bitcoin tube хайпы bitcoin bitcoin ваучер bitrix bitcoin ethereum контракты bitcoin tm bitcoin golden bitcoin community bitcoin сервисы биржи bitcoin
up bitcoin polkadot stingray 600 bitcoin ethereum виталий Per researchers, 'there is little sign of bitcoin use' in international remittances despite high fees charged by banks and Western Union who compete in this market. The South China Morning Post, however, mentions the use of bitcoin by Hong Kong workers to transfer money home.2moon bitcoin bitcoin png bitcoin валюты bitcoin обозреватель bitcoin china ethereum testnet контракты ethereum
capitalization cryptocurrency bitcoin stellar bitcoin 1000 bitcoin 999 difficulty bitcoin пирамида bitcoin forex bitcoin
bitcoin roulette ethereum обменять bitcoin москва bitcoin knots http bitcoin обменять monero bitcoin игры
addnode bitcoin bitcoin tor bitcoin trojan
bitcoin продам
world bitcoin
2x bitcoin bitcoin украина bitcoin capital platinum bitcoin bitcoin options bitcoin nvidia bitcoin parser продать bitcoin joker bitcoin zebra bitcoin bitcoin луна bitcoin explorer 1070 ethereum monster bitcoin 100 bitcoin sportsbook bitcoin bitcoin комиссия monero майнер